Construction of the controversial multi-billion rand improvement at the River Club in Observatory continues regardless of authorized challenges to the improvement.
Last week, an pressing software for an interdict was introduced by the Observatory Civic Association (OCA) towards the builders, Liesbeek Leisure Properties Trust (LLPT) for resuming work regardless of a courtroom order to halt building, pending the listening to of a contempt of courtroom software.
After listening to the software on Friday 2 September, Judge Mokgoatji Josiah Dolamo decided that the OCA’s software was not pressing, and dominated in favour of the LLPT administrators, who had been cited as respondents in their private capability.
This was the second time the OCA had introduced an pressing software to halt work on the website.
The first software, introduced by the OCA and the Goringhaicona Khoi Khoin Indigenous Traditional Council (GKKITC), pending a evaluate of the improvement authorisations granted by provincial and municipal authorities, was heard by Deputy Judge President Patricia Goliath in January.
Goliath handed down her judgment on 18 March, which ordered LLPT to halt building. Judge Goliath mentioned if work had been allowed to proceed, there was a hazard of LLPT constructing themselves into an “impregnable position”, as the improvement, which is to additionally home the new Africa headquarters for Amazon Web Services, may very well be primarily accomplished by the time a evaluate of the improvement authorisations can be heard.
She said there had been inadequate significant session by the builders with indigenous Khoi and San nations who considered the website at the confluence of the Liesbeek and Black Rivers as sacred.
Heritage assessments have decided the website to be of significance as it’s the place Dutch settlers first displaced the Khoi from their conventional grazing lands.
Judge Goliath rejected the LLPT’s depart to enchantment her order, however the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) subsequently granted them depart to enchantment. The LLPT resumed work on the website at the finish of June.
LLPT’s attorneys argue the enchantment, which is ready to be heard by a full bench of the Western Cape High Court on 11 and 12 October, nullifies the High Court order. Lawyers for the OCA, nonetheless, contend Goliath’s order was interlocutory, which means it stays in place till or except the courtroom guidelines in any other case.
This dispute about the interpretation of Judge Goliath’s order led to the OCA submitting a contempt of courtroom software, which was alleged to be heard on 22 August. However, the contempt of courtroom listening to was delayed and has nonetheless not been heard.
Judge Dolamo, in his ruling denying the OCA’s newest software for an pressing interdict resulting from the delay in the contempt of courtroom proceedings, said it was “not clear” why the contempt of courtroom software was not heard on that date.
However, lawyer Tim Dunn, on behalf of individuals claiming to be the reliable representatives of the GKKITC, utilized to intervene in proceedings on 22 August, the day of the listening to. Dunn’s shoppers claimed GKKITC Supreme High Commissioner Tauriq Jenkins, who had led the organisation in litigating towards the improvement, had no authority to take action. An earlier try by Dunn to depose Jenkins on an pressing foundation in July had been struck off the urgent roll by Judge Chantal Fortuin.
Dunn’s shoppers search a rescission of Goliath’s judgement, claiming it was fraudulently obtained as Jenkins had no authority to litigate on behalf of the GKKITC. The rescission software is now set to be heard with the enchantment earlier than a full bench on 11 and 12 October.
In a joint assertion, Jenkins and OCA chair Leslie London state it was Dunn’s failure to then file papers by 19 August in this regard that led to the contempt of courtroom matter not being heard on 22 August. Jenkins and London state they’re “disappointed he [Judge Dolamo] did not recognise this”.
With the contempt of courtroom listening to being pushed again and building persevering with apace, the OCA, now performing alone resulting from the allegations towards Jenkins, instructed attorneys Cullinan & Associates to use for an pressing interdict to halt additional work on the River Club website.
Judge Dolamo, nonetheless, dominated the software was not pressing, stating any urgency in the matter was self-created by the applicant, being the OCA. As a end result, he didn’t rule on whether or not Goliath’s order was remaining or interlocutory, leaving that for the contempt of courtroom hearings.
He additionally allowed the GKKITC, as represented by Dunn, to withdraw from the evaluate of the improvement authorisations and be cited as respondent in the matter, moderately than as applicant.
In an announcement, the OCA mentioned it was unclear what Judge Dolamo’s findings “regarding the individuals who claim to represent” the GKKITC means, as they didn’t apply for any reduction associated to enchantment towards Judge Goliath’s unique order.
The OCA said the contempt of courtroom hearings had been but to happen, and the courtroom might nonetheless discover that resuming work on website had been unlawful.
In an announcement posted on Facebook, LLPT welcomed Judge Dolamo’s ruling, and said the work on website “continues lawfully” pending the final result of the enchantment towards Judge Goliath’s order to be heard on 11 and 12 October.
© 2022 GroundUp.
This article was first printed on GroundUp, here.