CNN
 — 

The Biden administration has decided that Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince, Mohammed bin Salman, needs to be granted immunity in a case brought towards him by the fiancée of Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi, whom the administration has stated was murdered at the prince’s direction.

A courtroom submitting was made by Justice Department attorneys on the request of the State Department as a result of bin Salman was not too long ago made the Saudi prime minister and consequently, qualifies for immunity as a international head of presidency, the request stated. It was filed late Thursday night time, simply earlier than the courtroom’s deadline for the Justice Department to present its views in courtroom on the immunity query and different arguments the prince made for having the lawsuit dismissed.

“Mohammed bin Salman, the Prime Minister of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, is the sitting head of government and, accordingly, is immune from this suit,” the submitting reads, whereas calling the homicide “heinous.”

The choice is prone to provoke an indignant response. The White House had hoped the July journey by President Joe Biden to Saudi Arabia would get the rocky US-Saudi relationship again on monitor however since then, relations have solely continued to bitter.

The relationship is being reevaluated, the White House has stated, in the wake of an oil manufacturing minimize by Saudi-led OPEC+ that the administration noticed as a direct affront to the US. Members of Congress, already infuriated by the oil minimize and calling for a reevaluation, will doubtless solely be angered additional if the prince is given immunity.

Hatice Cengiz, Khashoggi’s fiancée, and the Washington-based human rights group that the late journalist based, DAWN, initially brought the lawsuit towards bin Salman and 28 others in October 2020 in the Washington, DC, Federal District Court. They allege that the workforce of assassins “kidnapped, bound, drugged, tortured, and assassinated” Khashoggi on the Saudi consulate in Istanbul after which dismembered his physique. His stays have by no means been discovered.

“Biden himself betrayed his word, betrayed Jamal,” Cengiz informed CNN. “History will not forget this wrong decision.”

Cengiz additionally tweeted, “Biden saved the murderer by granting immunity. He saved the criminal and got involved in the crime himself. Let’s see who will save you in the hereafter?”

The govt director of DAWN, Sarah Leah Whitson, known as the immunity request a “shocking outcome” and a “massive concession” to Saudi Arabia.

“It’s really beyond ironic that President Biden has basically delivered an assurance of impunity for Mohammed bin Salman, which is the exact opposite of what he promised to do to hold the killers of Jamal Khashoggi accountable,” Whitson informed CNN.

A US intelligence community report into Khashoggi’s homicide printed in February 2021 as Biden took workplace stated bin Salman permitted the operation to seize or kill the journalist which ended along with his homicide and dismemberment.

Bin Salman denied the allegations and sought immunity from prosecution, claiming that his varied authorities and royal positions gave him immunity and put him outdoors the US courts’ jurisdiction.

But as Crown Prince, bin Salman was not entitled to sovereign immunity which might usually simply embrace a head of state, head of presidency or international minister, none of which bin Salman was.

Then, only a few days earlier than the Biden administration was alleged to weigh in final month on the query of immunity, bin Salman was promoted to prime minister by his father, King Salman, who would usually maintain that place.

That was a “ploy” to safe so-called head of state immunity, DAWN’s Whitson stated, after which the Justice Department requested for a delay.

Now that bin Salman is prime minister, “the government ought to recommend that he’s entitled to immunity” stated regulation professor William Dodge on the University of California Davis Law School, who had beforehand written that the prince wasn’t entitled to immunity.

“It’s almost automatic,” Dodge stated, “I think that’s why he was appointed prime minister is to get out of this.”

The State Department was not required to make a dedication of immunity however was invited to take action by the courtroom. A spokesperson stated that their request that bin Salman be granted immunity is primarily based on longstanding frequent and worldwide regulation, relatively than a mirrored image of present diplomatic ties or efforts.

“This Suggestion of Immunity does not reflect an assessment on the merits of the case. It speaks to nothing on broader policy or the state of relations,” a division spokesperson informed CNN. “This was purely a legal determination.”

The Saudi embassy in Washington, DC, didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark.

Bin Salman had additionally claimed immunity in a case against him by former Saudi counterterrorism official Saad Aljabri, who accused the prince of sending a success squad to kill him in Canada simply days after Khashoggi’s homicide. That case was dismissed for different causes by the identical courtroom.

“After breaking its pledge to punish MBS for Khashoggi’s assassination, the Biden administration has not only shielded MBS from accountability in US courts, but effectively issued him license to kill more detractors and declared that he would never be held accountable,” Aljabri’s son, Khalid, informed CNN on Thursday.

The White House was extensively criticized for Biden’s journey to Saudi Arabia in July, when the president awkwardly fist-bumped the crown prince he stated he nonetheless holds accountable for Khashoggi’s homicide.

Biden stated he raised the killing firstly of their assembly and that the prince continued to disclaim being accountable.

“I was straightforward and direct in discussing it. I made my view crystal clear,” stated Biden.

The four-page US intelligence group report launched in 2021 stated that the 15-person Saudi workforce that arrived in Istanbul in October 2018 when Khashoggi was killed included members related to the Saudi Center for Studies and Media Affairs (CSMARC) on the Royal Court, led by an in depth adviser of bin Salman, in addition to “seven members of Muhammad bin Salman’s elite personal protective detail, known as the Rapid Intervention Force.”

The report famous that bin Salman seen Khashoggi as a risk to the Kingdom “and broadly supported using violent measures if necessary, to silence him.”

The intelligence report stated that they didn’t have visibility on when the Saudis had determined to hurt the daddy of 5. “Although Saudi officials had pre-planned an unspecified operation against Khashoggi we do not know how far in advance Saudi officials decided to harm him,” it stated.

Last month, on the fourth anniversary of Khashoggi’s demise, DAWN demanded the Biden administration declassify and publish the complete intelligence report on his killing.

Khashoggi’s fiancée Cengiz alleges that when Khashoggi tried to get the papers they wanted to get married on the embassy in Washington, DC, officers “manufactured an opportunity to murder him.”

They informed him the one place he might get the paperwork they wanted was on the consulate in Istanbul, she stated. Two weeks earlier than his appointment on October 2, 2018, the day he was killed, Khashoggi and Cengiz had been married in a non secular Islamic ceremony, the lawsuit says.

“The Administration’s decision to encourage courts to uphold MBS’ sovereign immunity is yet another disappointing chapter in a series of failures to hold Saudi leadership accountable for brutally murdering Jamal Khashoggi,” a senior congressional Democratic aide stated. “Actions such as this contradict the Administration’s hollow assurances of accountability and fly in the face of our own intelligence assessments of MBS’ involvement.”

CNN
 — 

A black-clad Iranian woman stands on high of an overturned rubbish bin, waving her headband as it’s engulfed by flames, amid chants of “death to the dictator.”

A second later, video reveals, she crouches to gather one other scarf, from a good friend, which she can even set on hearth in entrance of the protesters.

The woman was 16-year-old Nika Shahkarami, from Tehran. Just a few hours after these scenes have been recorded on September 20, in movies solely obtained and verified by CNN, Nika went lacking. ​And a couple of week later, her household realized that she was useless.

​Iranian authorities claimed Nika’s physique was discovered in the back of a courtyard on the morning of September 21. ​Her mom wasn’t given entry to establish her till 8 days later. CCTV footage launched by the authorities timestamped simply after midnight ​as September 20 ​grew to become September 21 ​confirmed the determine of a masked particular person they mentioned was Nika coming into a constructing ​that was uninhabited, and nonetheless below building in Tehran.

​A Tehran prosecutor initially mentioned she died after being thrown from the constructing’s roof, and that her dying “had no connection to the protests” of that day​, however regardless of apparently declaring her dying a murder, he didn’t say whether or not there have been suspects below investigation. State broadcasters reported that she “fell,” however didn’t present proof to assist the declare it was an accident.

On Wednesday, after CNN requested the federal government to remark on the proof on this investigation, an Iranian media report quoted a Tehran prosecutor as saying that Nika’s dying was a suicide. Iranian authorities nonetheless haven’t responded to CNN’s repeated inquiries about Nika’s dying.​​

​Authorities by no means defined why Nika would enter that constructing on her personal, and Nika’s mom has mentioned she doesn’t imagine the masked particular person is Nika. Her mom has mentioned she believes Nika was killed by the authorities, however the authorities have by no means mentioned whether or not Nika was of their custody at any level.

But dozens of movies and eyewitness accounts obtained solely by CNN point out that Nika seems to have been chased and detained by Iranian safety forces that night time. One key eyewitness, Ladan, advised CNN she noticed Nika being taken into custody ​on the protest by “several large-bodied plainclothes security officers” who bundled her right into a automotive.

Moments earlier, this witness, whereas caught in Tehran site visitors, filmed a video that purportedly reveals Shahkarami ducking behind a white automotive and yelling “tekoon nakon, tekoon nakon” – which implies “don’t move, don’t move” – to its driver earlier than working away from the transient shelter it gave her.

Seven individuals who knew Nika and spoke to CNN confirmed it was her. The similar footage, filmed at 8.37 p.m. on September 20, additionally reveals anti-riot police on bikes, patrolling the realm.

“I wanted to save her, but I couldn’t,” mentioned Ladan. “There were about 20 or 30 Basijis on motorcycles on the sidewalk​,” she mentioned, utilizing the native title for the paramilitary group that has been on the forefront of the state’s crackdown on protesters.

​”Shahkarami was throwing rocks at them. I used to be scared and I even went previous her and mentioned, ‘Be careful dear!’ as a result of there have been quite a few plainclothes police within the streets going by the vehicles on the lookout for her.

“Fifty meters ahead they got her,” Ladan added.

Ladan got here ahead to CNN after realising that {the teenager} she had filmed and spoken to was the one whose dying had been reported days later. CNN solely spoke to a number of witnesses who have been on the Tehran protest on September 20 with the assistance of activist group 1500Tasvir.

Other movies, together with the scarf-burning ones, are proof that Nika was on the forefront of the protests earlier within the night time, earlier than the crackdown began – fearlessly main chants and throwing rocks, in accordance to a number of testimonies.

That would have made her a goal for safety forces, together with members of Iran’s feared Basij militia, as they began to descend into the realm across the University of Tehran and Keshavarz Boulevard the place many of the protesters gathered that night, witnesses mentioned.

“I remember how brave she was because she would go up on the garbage bin and wouldn’t come down. She also burned her head scarf,” mentioned Najmeh, a protester who was with Nika on the demonstration.

CNN is utilizing pseudonyms for the entire witnesses quoted on this investigation, due to the danger to their security.

Students had gathered close to Laleh Park round 5 to 6 p.m. on September 20 to protest the dying of Mahsa Amini, a 22-year-old Kurdish-Iranian lady who died final month ​in state custody after being detained by the nation’s morality police​, allegedly for the way she was dressed.​

The scene was one which has turn into acquainted in Tehran in current weeks: younger individuals, principally ladies, chanting “death to the dictator,” burning headscarves and throwing rocks towards safety forces.

At one level, a trash bin was introduced over and overturned to block the street. Nika hopped on high together with a few others, video footage confirmed.

“She burned her head scarf and waved it. I told her not to wave it because you could burn yourself, just hold it until it burns,” mentioned Nima, who was additionally on the protest and noticed the occasions unfold. “Then she took the headscarves of the two friends who were with her and burned those as well.”

In different movies ​from that night geolocated and verified by CNN, Nika is proven hurling rocks at anti-riot police forces. She’s carrying a particular CAT rucksack and sporting a black masks and hat on her head. ​Sounds that seem to be gunshots might be heard.

From 7 to 8 p.m., the safety forces’ crackdown intensified, witnesses mentioned. “They were firing tear gas and pellet shots and grabbing protesters. Almost all of us were confronting them and running away,” mentioned Reza, one other witness.

As anti-riot police and Basij forces crammed the streets, protesters began to transfer in all instructions to escape the crackdown.

Another witness, Dina, who spent among the protest strolling alongside Nika, advised CNN she noticed Nika in entrance of a fuel station not removed from the University of Tehran, the place the group of protesters had gathered after fleeing tear fuel launched by the safety forces. Others managed to seize on video these being detained by what appeared to be plainclothes officers.

Reza added: “I saw with my own eyes security forces hitting women with batons, and they grabbed many of them and took them to police vans.”

It is on this context of maximum repression of the protest that Nika ​was final seen by the witnesses who spoke to CNN – and 9 extra days would move earlier than her household was given official phrase of her whereabouts. Videos verified and geolocated by CNN show that the woman, within the final witness footage offered to CNN exhibiting her alive, was hemmed in by safety forces on three sides.

“I think Nika got stuck that night when we were running away. Because she was very young,” Dina mentioned.

While Iranian authorities insist Nika died ​on the grounds of that uninhabited constructing, her mom Nasrin advised Etemad, an unbiased Iranian newspaper, in an interview revealed on October 10 that she believes her daughter “was at the protests and killed there.”

Iranian safety forces arrested eight individuals who have been employees within the constructing which Nika allegedly entered ​a couple of hours after eyewitnesses noticed her on the September 20 protests, state-aligned information company Tasnim reported on October 4. Tehran’s prosecutor Ali Salehi mentioned a judicial prison case had been launched and expressed his condolences to Nika’s household, state run IRNA mentioned.

Mohammad Shahriari, the pinnacle of prison prosecution of Tehran province, initially mentioned Nika’s accidents corresponded with ​having been “thrown down,” citing an post-mortem that exposed a number of fractures within the space of the pelvis, head, higher and decrease limbs, palms​, toes ​and hip, Tasnim reported.

He added that “an investigation showed this incident had no connection to the protests. No bullet holes were found on the body.”

CNN has repeatedly sought remark from the Iranian authorities on whether or not Nika was detained on the protests that night time and whether or not different ladies have been assaulted and put in police autos. CNN additionally requested the Tehran prosecutor’s workplace concerning the standing of the prison investigation into Nika’s dying. No responses have been acquired prior to the publication of this story.

​On Wednesday, the web information outlet Mizan, which is affiliated with Iran’s judiciary, revealed a report saying that Nika’s dying had been a suicide, citing a prosecutor from t

However, a dying certificates first seen by BBC Persian and verified by CNN states that Shahkarami died from a number of accidents attributable to blows with a tough object.

In the Etemad interview, Nasrin mentioned she had spoken by cellphone with Shahkarami many occasions on the day she disappeared. The background noise throughout the calls indicated she and the opposite protesters have been fleeing from safety forces, Nasrin added. ​

Nika additionally talked about a couple of places she was in – Enghelab Square, Keshavarz Boulevard and Valiasr avenue – in accordance to Nasrin, which match the movies geolocated by CNN.

Nasrin final spoke with her daughter simply earlier than midnight, she mentioned, and after that, all her makes an attempt to name Nika indicated that Nika’s cellphone had been disconnected. Nika’s Instagram and Telegram accounts have been deleted, in accordance to Nika’s aunt and several other protesters who spoke to CNN.

For days, her household says they went to police stations, jails, and hospitals on the lookout for traces of her, all to no avail. Finally, on September 30, Nika’s mom and brother have been requested to establish Nika’s corpse, she advised BBC Persian. ​

​On October 6, in an interview with Radio Farda, Nasrin claimed that whereas she and different family members have been on the lookout for Nika within the days after her disappearance, one particular person gave her Nika’s nationwide ID quantity and advised her “the IRGC got her, they wanted to slowly interrogate her.”

That matches what Shahkarami’s aunt, Atash, told BBC Persian quickly after she disappeared. “An unofficial source from the IRGC themselves got in touch with me and said, this kid was in our custody a week ago, and after we were done interrogating and building the case file, 1 or 2 days ago ​(she) was transferred to Evin prison,” Atash mentioned.

Atash and Nika’s uncle, Mohsen, have been subsequently arrested by Iranian safety forces and compelled to make a false assertion, according to BBC Persian​, citing a supply shut to the household. Following the BBC’s reporting, when reached by CNN, Atash requested not to be contacted once more, citing security issues.

While the household searches for solutions, the individuals who have been with Nika on that day are additionally nonetheless reeling from her dying.

“The situation was very scary, and everyone thought of escaping,” Dina mentioned. “I can’t forgive myself for Nika’s death. She was a child.”