In the energy and electricity sectors of South Africa, there may be a lot that may very well be performed and ought to be performed, that’s not being performed. On the shiny aspect, this ought to be a trigger for some optimism, because it factors to the large opportunities which are inside our grasp.
There can be good trigger for pessimism if we had been doing a lot of the proper stuff, whereas nonetheless remaining caught in the present mess.
The function of this text is to spotlight the substantial challenges that we ought to be addressing, and, in so doing, admire and perceive the vital opportunities that exist by efficiently addressing just a few of these.
Energy and electricity coverage
South Africa has skilled a backwards-looking failure by leaders at the highest stage to grasp and reply to challenges dealing with the worldwide and native energy and electricity sectors, and to adapt accordingly.
Over-complicated and outdated oversight and governance preparations by an extreme quantity of authorities departments and companies, along with insufficient coverage, regulatory, planning and oversight capability for the electricity provide and distribution industries of South Africa, are plainly evident.
These governance and oversight our bodies embody the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE), the Department of Public Enterprises (DPE), National Treasury, the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta), the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE), the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (Nersa) and the South African Local Government Association (Salga).
At the similar time, ongoing energy and electricity coverage uncertainty, mixed with combined messaging emanating from the Presidency, the Presidential Climate Commission (PCC), National Treasury, DMRE, DPE and DFFE, is including to the toll which common load shedding is taking up financial development, enterprise confidence and funding.
Read: FirstRand chair slams ‘glacial’ tempo of Ramaphosa’s infrastructure programme
In 2022, the frequency and depth of load shedding to guard the nationwide grid reached new file highs. Data from famend load shedding app, EskomSePush, signifies that the nationwide utility did not ship an estimated 11 797 GWh of energy throughout 3 775 hours of rolling energy cuts in 2022, some 4.73 occasions increased than the 2496 GWh of unserved energy ensuing from 1 153 hours of energy cuts in 2021.
Fig 1: Estimated annual unserved energy on account of load shedding by Eskom from 2015 to 2022. (Data supply: Stage 1 (1 GW) to Stage 6 (6 GW) Eskom load-shed hours, from EskomSePush; Graph: EE Business Intelligence.)There is clearly a necessity for extra constant, coherent and well-articulated energy and electricity insurance policies and methods in South Africa. However, there may be an obvious lack of ability and/or unwillingness by politicians and the authorities to recognise, take accountability for and/or confront the worsening energy and electricity disaster head-on.
Electricity regulation
The present electricity regulatory framework in South Africa is now not fit-for-purpose in the quickly altering world energy and electricity setting, and there may be insufficient coverage course, capability, regulatory independence and flexibility to regulate and adapt the nation’s regulatory framework to one thing extra acceptable.
This is evidenced by ongoing regulatory failures in the electricity sector as indicated by a number of courtroom judgements in opposition to Nersa, following authorized motion by Eskom difficult the regulator’s electricity value determinations and methodology.
Read: Nersa methodology for municipal electricity tariffs ‘unlawful, invalid’ [Oct 2022]
Court orders Nersa to course of Eskom tariff utility [Dec 2021]
Nersa retracts a number of earlier selections, awards Eskom extra R6bn [Jan 2021]
Ongoing delays in promulgating amendments to the Electricity Regulation Act (ERA) that would supply the crucial authorized, regulatory and planning framework for a restructured electricity provide business are additionally holding again reform of the electricity sector.
Electricity pricing
Failure by Nersa to implement constant, predictable and sustainable cost-reflective electricity tariffs in South Africa has considerably broken Eskom and the economic system.
Delays in setting up an amended nationwide electricity pricing coverage and methodology for the nation are additional inhibiting reform and restructuring of the electricity provide and distribution industries.
In the meantime, ongoing functions by Eskom and municipal distributors to Nersa for very excessive electricity value will increase underneath the present preparations are fuelling inflation, making electricity unaffordable and growing electricity theft, non-payment and municipal arrear debt.
Despite a number of years of discussions, Nersa and municipal electricity distributors have failed to arrange and implement a nationwide municipal wheeling framework and related wheeling tariffs for transport of electricity throughout municipal networks from distributed mills to off-takers embedded with municipal networks.
Similarly, Eskom and most municipal distributors nonetheless should not have Nersa-approved feed-in tariffs for home, industrial, industrial, mining and agricultural photo voltaic photovoltaic and battery energy storage installations, and don’t but allow era into the community by low-voltage electricity clients.
Energy and electricity planning
The absence of a complete nationwide built-in energy plan (IEP), an up to date built-in useful resource plan for electricity (IRP), and coal, liquid fuels and fuel roadmap plans for South Africa, is an indication that planning in the energy and electricity sectors is way from ample.
There have been execution delays and poor communication of progress made in implementing concrete plans and actions to finish load shedding quick by the National Energy Crisis Committee (NECCOM) introduced by the President on 26 July 2022.
For instance, there’s a lack of any seen implementation of the best and quickest actions in the emergency plan to finish load shedding, specifically, to permit, encourage and incentivise home, industrial and agricultural electricity clients to complement their grid electricity wants with embedded photo voltaic photovoltaic and battery energy storage methods.
New era capability
The course of of ministerial determinations and concurrence by Nersa for brand new era capability procurements in accordance with an outdated built-in useful resource plan for electricity, is gradual, bureaucratic and now not match for function.
Unrealistic localisation necessities, adjustments in native and worldwide energy and electricity enterprise environments, and difficulties in acquiring Eskom grid entry, have resulted in failures to achieve monetary shut by many tasks of Bid Windows 5 and 6 of the Renewable Energy IPP Procurement (REIPPP) programme. This has brought about delays in the procurement and building of new era capability through the Risk Mitigation IPP Procurement (RMIPPP) and REIPPP programmes.
In addition, the gas-to-power, imported hydro, new coal-fired energy and battery energy storage public procurement processes of the DMRE’s IPP Office are but to begin.
With 11 GW of ageing coal-fired energy stations due for decommissioning by 2030, and insufficient new era capability set to come back on-line in the meantime, the outlook for safety of provide in South Africa is bleak.
Eskom
The unsustainable monetary, operational and environmental place of South Africa’s nationwide electricity utility, Eskom, has been obvious for years.
Finally, after a number of years of discuss, decision of Eskom’s debt place by authorities taking on a good portion of Eskom’s debt is predicted be introduced by the finish of February 2023. This will strengthen Eskom’s steadiness sheet and assist its monetary sustainability, however it doesn’t handle the underlying structural points.
Read: R30bn lifeline for Denel, Sanral and Transnet [Oct 2022]
SA seeks unbiased recommendation on Eskom debt aid [Oct 2022]
Godongwana says Eskom debt plan stays on observe [Dec 2022]
Investments in upgrading, strengthening and increasing the nationwide electricity grid and related transmission and distribution substations to supply ample grid entry at the moment are crucial to keep away from grid congestion in sure areas and to accommodate the connection of new era capability.
However, frequent adjustments in Eskom’s govt administration are unsettling, and visionary, forward-looking board and govt appointments are wanted to allow Eskom to navigate the existential threats it faces, and to remodel to grow to be a utility of the future.
Generation plant efficiency
Eskom’s poor operational efficiency is indicated by the declining energy availability issue (EAF) of the utility’s fleet of coal-fired and nuclear-powered base-supply mills, which in the ultimate weeks of 2022 dropped considerably beneath 50%.
Fig. 2: Eskom complete week-on-week energy availability issue (EAF), from Week 1, 2016 to Week 51, 2022.
(Data supply: Eskom; Graph: EE Business Intelligence)
Load shedding in South Africa is worsened by insufficient era capability reserves to supply the crucial headroom for the required deep-level upkeep of the poorly performing coal-fired fleet of mills.
To meet demand over the previous few years, Eskom has more and more relied on the use of its emergency, diesel-powered, open-cycle fuel generators (OCGTs) to fulfill demand, thereby persistently exceeding its diesel price range.
In November 2022, the utility had spent about R12 billion on diesel, double the 12 months’s preliminary price range. And in the absence of additional monetary assist from authorities, Eskom was compelled to chop again on diesel utilization, and implement extra intense load shedding.
The failure of Eskom to fulfill the legally required minimal emission requirements (MES) of South Africa at just about all of Eskom’s coal-fired energy stations, with no plans in place to fulfill these requirements in the foreseeable future, poses additional large dangers to the safety of provide in South Africa.
In 2022, the DFFE ordered the shutdown of a quantity of Eskom coal-fired energy stations because of this of non-compliance with the MES for over a decade. The loss of some 16 GW of energy era capability now hinges on the consequence of an enchantment lodged by Eskom.
Municipal electricity distribution
In many areas of the nation, the dysfunctional and unsustainable monetary and operational state of many municipalities and municipal electricity distributors in South Africa presents as a lot of a problem as load shedding by Eskom.
A major quantity of municipalities and municipal electricity distributors are unable to fulfill funds for his or her present electricity purchases from Eskom, service their arrear debt, or meet compensation preparations on this debt. Municipal arrear debt to Eskom presently stands at above R50 billion.
Read: Eskom goes after delinquent municipality’s financial institution accounts [July 2022]
Mangaung and Ekurhuleni battling to pay Eskom [Sept 2022]
Salga slams proposed Eskom settlement with Maluti-A-Phofung [Nov 2022]
Most municipalities and municipal electricity distributors additionally fail to supply free fundamental electricity to the vital majority of indigent households of their areas of provide and as a substitute misappropriate about 70% of the funds budgeted and disbursed by National Treasury for this particular function.
A backwards-looking method to electricity distribution by the municipal electricity distribution sector and Nersa has inhibited the implementation of feed-in tariffs for embedded era and battery energy storage in South Africa.
Similarly, electricity distribution sector seems unable or unwilling to formulate and implement a nationwide municipal wheeling tariff framework and related wheeling tariffs in South Africa.
Payment for electricity
Where there are excessive ranges of overloading on account of unlawful connections, electricity theft and non-payment of electricity, Eskom has been focusing on areas provided straight by the utility with cut-offs throughout peak durations, a apply euphemistically often called “load reduction”.
The greatest problem in these Eskom provide areas is in Soweto, the place the stage of non-payment is round 80%, and the place a tradition of non-payment and resistance to the set up of prepayment meters has existed for many years. Failures in addressing electricity theft and non-payment in Soweto has resulted in Eskom recurrently having to jot down off billions of rands of arear debt by residents.
Read: Government and Eskom can unwell afford to soak up Soweto’s electricity payments [Nov 2022]
In current weeks, Eskom has been focusing on municipal electricity distributors having excessive ranges of arrear debt with extra rotating cut-offs, over and above that required by the regular load shedding schedules. The scenario is now approaching disaster proportions, with Salga urging municipalities to withstand Eskom’s efforts to get well municipal arrear debt.
Electricity sector reform and restructuring
Despite being a key half of the 1998 Government White Paper on Energy Policy, and the 2019 Eskom Roadmap revealed by the DPE, delays in electricity sector reform and restructuring proceed to this present day.
Talk of unbundling Eskom to ascertain an unbiased National Transmission Company of South Africa (NTCSA), a diversified aggressive era sector, and day-ahead, balancing and ancillary service electricity markets, remains to be ongoing.
However, greater than a 12 months because it was established as a authorized entity and subsidiary of Eskom, Nersa has nonetheless not processed a transmission licence for NTCSA, the DPE minister has but to nominate a board of administrators for the firm, and NTCSA remains to be not operational.
Work on the rationalisation and restructuring of the electricity distribution sector was deserted in 2010, and the separation of the electrical energy and wires companies, and the institution of a aggressive retail electricity sector in South Africa, has not even began.
A longstanding disagreement between Eskom and municipalities represented by Salga, in respect of claims by municipalities for unique authority over electricity distribution and reticulation in South Africa, might be heard in the High Court in 2023.
However, no matter the consequence in the High Court, the matter seems set to be heading to the Supreme Court of Appeal and Constitutional Court, and the dispute might nonetheless take some years to resolve.
Criminality
Increasing ranges of electricity, metal, copper, aluminium conductor and cable theft, in addition to vandalism of electricity infrastructure and threats to personnel, are reaching a stage the place Eskom and municipalities are starting to desert sure areas of provide as “no-go” zones.
In addition, maladministration, procurement irregularities, fraud, corruption, criminality and sabotage inside Eskom and its energy stations, and at municipalities and their electricity distributors, is a significant problem, to the extent that the military has been deployed to guard property at a quantity of Eskom energy stations.
It is clear that there exists a major lack of capability by the South African Police Service (SAPS), by specialised crime investigative, prosecuting and enforcement authorities, and by the justice division, to deliver electricity criminals to guide.
Conclusion
From the multitude of challenges dealing with the electricity provide and distribution industries of South Africa, it’s clear there are certainly vital opportunities that may very well be realised by efficiently addressing just a few of these.
However, a continued failure to deal with these challenges could have the inevitable end result of ongoing financial decline and loss of confidence by residents and enterprise entities in South Africa, resulting in political, financial and social instability.
Chris Yelland, managing director, EE Business Intelligence
© Copyright 2023 – EE Business Intelligence (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved. This article is revealed with permission.
