Legislative change aimed toward stopping revenue shifting, is having a adverse impression on favourable tax regimes designed to appeal to international direct funding and help South Africa’s industrialisation efforts.
One such regime noticed the introduction of particular financial zones that supply a lowered company tax fee of 15% and an accelerated capital allowance to qualifying firms.
The Special Economic Zones (SEZ) Act was supposed to come into operation in 2014, however this solely occurred two years later, and the approval of particular SEZs was solely revealed in 2018. Since then some adjustments have been launched to stop tax leakage.
Shifting goalposts led to conditions the place firms that, in 2014 made funding choices to relocate their companies to these particular demarcated areas in SA, discovered themselves disqualified in 2020.
During the December digital workshops hosted by National Treasury on technical proposals for the February 2023 funds, affected stakeholders and SEZ practitioners raised their issues concerning the impression of anti-avoidance measures on the success of the regime.
One SEZ practitioner stated though he understands the significance of defending the fiscus towards revenue shifting, there are other ways to mitigate the dangers.
Read: Special Economic Zone regime proposals ‘make no sense’
In phrases of the anti-avoidance rule, an organization is disqualified from the lowered fee incentive if transactions with linked individuals who’re resident (or non-resident, however with the transactions attributable to a South African everlasting institution of the non-resident) give rise to greater than 20% of its deductible expenditure incurred or greater than 20% of its earnings acquired or accrued.
Compensation?
A consultant from electronics firm Samsung needed to know whether or not firms that relocated their manufacturing operations to SA on the premise of the particular tax regime – as Samsung did – might be compensated as a result of the principles had been modified.
Treasury discovered this request “weird” and famous that it shouldn’t be construed that the 15% fee was taken away.
When KwaZulu-Natal’s Dube Tradeport’s SEZ standing was authorized, Samsung turned one the primary firms to take up the provide – establishing its African manufacturing facility throughout the zone.
Its consultant stated though the corporate appreciates the truth that the 20% rule is an anti-avoidance measure, it’s a “common type of business model” for separate authorized entities to be arrange for manufacturing or manufacturing and gross sales.
According to stakeholders the principle focus of incentives such because the SEZ regime needs to be to appeal to investments that may introduce ‘additionality’ and new know-how into the economic system.
This isn’t achievable if authorities continues to change the principles of the sport.
Read: Little-known tax incentives increase enterprise case for renewable power
Companies have turn into cautious
South Africa was ready to appeal to a number one firm like Samsung in 2014, however multinationals have turn into extra cautious as a result of of uncertainty across the regime and the way it could have an effect on the best way they conduct their enterprise.
Currently the principles state {that a} qualifying firm have to be integrated by regulation; have its place of efficient administration in South Africa and stick with it a commerce inside a delegated SEZ; have not more than 20% of expenditure that’s deductible incurred with a linked particular person; and have not more than 20% of earnings acquired or accrued from a linked particular person.
During the workshop Treasury was urged to contemplate scrapping the 20% rule and to make use of different out there anti-avoidance mechanisms and for the South African Revenue Service to improve its capabilities to monitor and detect revenue shifting.
Government is within the course of of reviewing the efficacy of a number of of its tax incentives and has made bulletins about some of them that won’t proceed past their sundown dates.
Read:
The SEZ regime will proceed till 1 January 2031.