JSE-listed Spar’s newest full-12 months outcomes fell in need of market expectations and noticed its share value slide nearly 13% on Wednesday to shut at R144.10.
At the start of November final 12 months (2021), Spar stood at round R200 a share.
The grocery wholesale and distribution group reported a lower in full-12 months earnings per share (EPS) of 4.9% to 1 18.2 cents, whereas diluted headline earnings per share (Heps) fell 2.9%, to 1 159.1 cents.
Read: Spar shares slide as group slashes FY dividend by 51%
Sasfin senior fairness analyst Alec Abraham tells Moneyweb that though comprehensible, he’s shocked on the extent of the market’s response to Spar’s 2022 full-12 months outcomes.
“I wasn’t anticipating this unhealthy a response from the market to be utterly sincere, however mainly the negatives had been that they missed expectations.
“Most analysts were looking for 3% to 5% earnings growth and they came in at minus 3%.”
Abraham says the drop within the share value can be attributed to the weak efficiency of its South Africa operations.
Competitively sluggish …
Although the grocery retail sector hasn’t totally recovered from the results of the Covid-19 pandemic, Abraham notes that Spar’s rivals are a minimum of making strides in attempting to get again to the pre-pandemic glory days – whereas its restoration has remained disappointingly sluggish.
For the total 12 months, Spar’s core wholesale grocery enterprise grew gross sales by 4.6%, whereas for the 12 months ending July, competitor Shoprite reported a double-digit (10.1%) enhance in gross sales inside its South African supermarkets enterprise.
Read:
Shoprite steams forward, with double-digit earnings and dividend progress
Woolworths flags increased revenue as Covid disruption eases
Pick n Pay posts sturdy double-digit HY revenue progress
“What was certainly bad for me was that [Spar’s] South African operations appeared to be very weak again. Its sales growth in South Africa appeared to be very weak when you compared them to Pick n Pay and Shoprite, it was very poor,” says Abraham.
New dividend coverage
Another issue contributing to the market’s response is the group’s momentary coverage to direct dividends away from shareholders and in direction of financing the implementation of methods upgrades throughout its operations in addition to different progress tasks.
The coverage – introduced in February – was carried out for the primary time this 12 months and was the explanation behind Spar’s dividend being greater than 50% decrease than the one declared for the prior monetary 12 months.
“I think it’s prudent they decided to lower the dividend to pay for certain expenses,” says Abraham.
“When you consider that as an investor you’ve already gotten quite a poor return on your Spar shares, and now they cut the dividend as well, clearly the market was unhappy with that as well.”
Poland losses
Spar’s enterprise in Poland continued to register losses in FY2022, albeit at decrease ranges.
Spar Poland lowered its working losses by 15.5% in reporting forex phrases, to R403 million. This was down from losses of R477.2 million for the prior monetary 12 months.
This enterprise is battling quite a few challenges, together with elevated operational prices in gasoline and vitality – a pattern noticed within the group’s different European operations as nicely.
The group additionally reported that it misplaced 58 retailers in Poland as a consequence of low ranges of buying loyalty – however identified that it had signed new contracts that higher defend the Poland operations.
“The new contracts required a minimum level of retailer loyalty and consequently retailer loyalty for the retailers in the south reached 40% from 27% in the prior period,” it stated.
Abraham says buyers had been hoping for a greater enchancment in Poland.
“They still did relatively well on their top line in Poland,” he provides, “and more importantly, because the loyalty levels of those [retailers] who’ve stayed is much higher, it improves the efficiency of the distribution centre, and their margin improved quite substantially.”