The revival of fossil fuels in European power coverage dangers triggering the first wave of monetary penalties within the international market for ESG bonds.
A take a look at case is about to unfold in Greece, the place power provider Public Power Corp. might discover it “virtually impossible” to fulfill the end-of-year emissions goal on some of its debt, in response to an evaluation carried out by the Anthropocene Fixed Income Institute.
That’s as regulators, authorities officers and trade representatives agree on disaster insurance policies which might be delaying the corporate’s phase-out of lignite coal manufacturing, which might additionally make it difficult to fulfill a separate end-2023 goal, AFII stated.
The debt in query is a sustainability-linked bond. SLBs sometimes see issuers pay a penalty in the event that they miss pre-determined environmental, social or governance objectives. But with Europe’s choice to ramp up coal manufacturing in response to the present power disaster, near-term local weather commitments are being derailed. And that’s left many utilities with little alternative however to adapt.
PPC “takes its environmental and social role very seriously,” a spokesperson for the Athens-based firm stated in an emailed remark. “In this context and prior to the energy crisis and the conflict in Ukraine, PPC has communicated an aggressive delignitization plan, adopting a move toward renewable energy sources which would lead to substantial reductions in CO2 emissions.”
The present state of affairs “may result in the step-up clause on our SLB bonds to be put in place,” the spokesperson stated. “However, given our stated commitments, we do not see issues with our credit institutions, debt holders or credit agencies from the enforcement of the step-up.”
In July, it emerged that PPC deliberate to double its output from lignite coal over the subsequent 12 months, to make sure demand may be met. That’s as Russia’s invasion of Ukraine disrupts provides and forces a rethink of power coverage throughout Europe. It’s a sample that threatens to repeat itself throughout the broader SLB market, as issuers that had set emissions targets wrestle with the fallout of the power disaster.
Market development
Global SLB gross sales grew nearly tenfold final yr to round $108 billion, in response to Bloomberg Intelligence, with a further $80 billion to date in 2022. The debt differs from the better-established inexperienced bond market, the place proceeds are earmarked for environmental tasks. Funds raised by means of SLBs can be utilized for something, boosting their enchantment for issuers.
The fast development in SLBs has additionally attracted criticism, with weak and versatile targets alongside tiny penalties leaving some collectors cautious. A quantity of the world’s largest ESG bond buyers refuse to the touch SLBs, whereas early buyers have voiced issues that corners of the market danger shedding credibility.
The first ever SLB was bought by Italian utility Enel SpA in 2019. The firm faces an end-2023 goal that has additionally been made harder to achieve by adjustments in Europe’s power coverage, in response to AFII stated.
“Our view on Enel is that even if a Sustainability Performance Target is missed, it does not necessarily represent a detrimental adjustment to its sustainability targets, and should not be accompanied by a downgrade in credit,” AFII stated. “A coupon step-up, potentially accompanied by technical selling from green funds, could present an attractive opportunity to increase exposure if investors believe in the company’s long-term sustainability performance.”
A spokesperson for Enel declined to remark, citing the corporate’s silent interval forward of its enterprise technique presentation subsequent week.
PPC bought two sustainability-linked bonds final yr. The first, a €775 million safety maturing in 2026, pays a half-a-percentage-point coupon step-up if it fails to cut back direct emissions from its belongings by 40% by end-2022, from a 2019 base yr. That works out to round €3.9 million per yr if PPC doesn’t obtain the purpose.
The firm stated it has “successfully phased out 1.4GW of capacity” since 2021, resulting in a 30% discount of CO2 emissions in comparison with 2019.
“However, the conflict in Ukraine in the beginning of 2022 has created significant energy related issues throughout Europe,” the spokesperson stated. These are developments that have been “unforeseen.”
A novelty
Witnessing an SLB set off go off can be a novelty in worldwide markets. Most issuers’ both have targets which might be a number of years away, or so unambitious that they are often simply met even in tough markets.
UK grocery chain Tesco Plc was criticized final yr for tying its SLB to objectives that lined solely 2% of annual emissions. France’s Carrefour SA raised eyebrows by leaving out emission-reduction targets altogether.
As a consequence, there’s no playbook to point out how markets will react when targets are missed, the AFII stated. Investors would get the next coupon, which might increase demand for the bond. On the opposite hand, an issuer’s failure to fulfill an ESG goal would possibly spark a selloff by funds which have sustainable funding mandates.
“This relationship would need to be considered on a case-by-case basis,” the AFII stated. “Watching SLBs as they go through their triggers should give pricing information that can be used for this purpose.”
© 2022 Bloomberg