South African telecommunications provider, Cell C, has been in financial distress for years, despite multiple recapitalisation efforts.
Mail & Guardian recently reported that this once trailblazing telecommunications provider’s financial situation remains precarious.
As the telecommunication provider with the fourth and smallest market share of South Africa’s four mobile networks, mounting debts, weakening sales and even considerations of slashing its workforce, Cell C has seen challenges that extend far beyond mere rebranding, and so, what are the viable solutions for Cell C’s survival?
A Turnaround Strategy: Merger or Acquisition?
As an initial consideration, the potential for a merger or acquisition by one of its competitors must be taken seriously. With Cell C reportedly considering slashing its workforce by 40%, as highlighted by TechPoint, it’s clear that drastic measures are on the table. But would its competitors even entertain such a move?
South Africa’s telecommunications industry functions as an oligopoly, meaning the industry is dominated by a few large players being Vodacom, MTN, and Telkom. These companies hold significant market share, and their influence on pricing and service offerings is substantial.
If a merger or acquisition were to be entertained, the Competition Commission would play a critical role in deciding the fate of such a deal.
Recent approvals granted by the Competition Commission; as seen when the Competition Commission green-lit The Prepaid Company’s (Blue Label Telecoms subsidiary) acquisition of Cell C, showcase the commission’s willingness to consider consolidations if they meet specific criteria and do not raise public interest concerns.
These criteria or so-called merger conditions, include preventing a monopolistic market while ensuring consumer choice and market competition are maintained, as well as the likelihood of positive outcomes such as increased black economic participation and unemployment reduction.
Given these factors, a merger involving Cell C could be seen as a way to stabilise the industry and offer consumers more reliable service options. However, competition concerns may arise, as the elimination of a major player could further concentrate power in the hands of a few dominant firms.
Case for a Merger: Competition Commission Considerations
The question of whether Cell C can merge with another telecom giant must take into account South Africa’s competition regulations. South African Competition law ensures that mergers and acquisitions do not result in reduced consumer choice or create a monopolistic market.
In an oligopoly, the reduction of one competitor could be perceived as harmful. However, in Cell C’s case, the company’s weakening financial position may justify its absorption by a larger competitor. From an economic perspective, consolidation could streamline operations and allow for more efficient service delivery.
The commission’s past rulings on mergers in other industries indicate that a carefully structured deal could pass, especially if it maintains competitive pricing structures and consumer benefits, as highlighted by The Conversation.
Failing Firm Defence and ICASA Approval
An additional point to consider in favour of a merger or acquisition is the failing firm defence. Under antitrust or competition law, this defence allows for an otherwise anticompetitive acquisition if the acquiree is facing imminent failure and there are no other viable alternatives for survival. The key thresholds for invoking this defence include (1) the likelihood of business failure, (2) the inevitability of its assets exiting the market, and (3) the absence of other potential buyers.
Given Cell C’s ongoing financial struggles, the company could argue that a merger or acquisition is a preferable alternative to complete market exit. However, Cell C would still need to prove that no other acquirer could offer a less anti-competitive solution.
Moreover, any merger would require separate approval from the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA). As a mobile network operator, Cell C operates under licences governed by the Electronic Communications Act. A change in shareholding or control requires ICASA’s prior approval, ensuring that such a deal complies with relevant legislation.
Other Potential Turnaround Strategies
Beyond mergers, there are several other potential strategies that Cell C could explore. One example is cost restructuring, as seen in the Kenyan telecommunications industry with Telkom Kenya.
According to scholarly researcher Joseph Kipkeu Kimutai, following unprecedented losses experienced over the course of several years, Telkom Kenya took active steps to implement a turnaround strategy which included aggressive cost-cutting and focusing on core business activities to ensure financial stability. In this regard, Cell C has already considered workforce reductions, but it may need to go further in trimming non-essential services and focusing on its most profitable offerings.
Another potential strategy is innovation in service delivery. Cell C could differentiate itself by offering unique, customer-centric services that set it apart from competitors. ITWeb has already highlighted some of Cell C’s repositioning and renewal strategies, which is particularly crucial in a market where larger players dominate, niche differentiation could be the key to survival.
Merger, Reinvention or the End for Cell C?
Cell C’s financial struggles may ultimately lead to a merger or acquisition as its only viable path to survival. While the company has attempted to rebrand and restructure, these efforts may not be enough to stave off the financial pressures it faces and regain market relevance.
While a merger with a competitor could offer a lifeline, the company will need to navigate regulatory hurdles and adapt to the shifting landscape of competitive pressures and economic realities if it hopes to survive in South Africa’s challenging telecom landscape.
What do you think Cell C’s next move should be? Can a merger save the company, or is there another path to recovery?
Let us know by clicking on the comment tab below this article or by emailing info@thesouthafrican.com or sending a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. You can also follow @TheSAnews on X and The South African on Facebook for the latest news.
