You may also take heed to this podcast on iono.fm here.
This transcript is a translation from the unique interview, which was carried out in Afrikaans and aired on RSG Geldsake, right here.
RYK VAN NIEKERK: Mines are certainly one of South Africa’s most necessary financial sectors and though they contribute solely 8.7% to the gross home product, additionally they assist varied different sectors such because the manufacturing and logistics sectors. The mining sector gives greater than 460 000 jobs and in 2021 paid the federal government round R120 billion in tax and royalties. If staff’ earnings tax on this sector is included, that offered R150 billion to the fiscus. The sector additionally exported minerals price R840 billion.
Kobus Nell is a portfolio supervisor at Stanlib and is on the road. Kobus, a heat welcome to the programme. The figures I’ve quoted come from analysis by the Minerals Council [of South Africa] relative to 2021, and in lots of respects 2021 was a report yr. How do mining sector exercise ranges for this yr, 2022, examine to these of final yr?
KOBUS NELL: Hello Ryk, and hiya to all of the listeners. I feel if one seems at this yr as a yr by which South African mining corporations revenue[ed]… significantly from the comparatively excessive costs of platinum group metals specifically, and secondly from coal. That’s an enormous benefit that authorities has loved in a really troublesome interval by way of the extra taxes it might acquire.
In the fiscus we noticed the diploma to which earnings was derived from mining actions and the way, I’d say, it plugged holes.
And, if I take a look at the nation’s indebtedness, even when issues regarded determined by means of the Covid interval with the extra expenditure, it was within the severe place getting again to that degree of indebtedness. As you talked about, that doesn’t embody the advantages for employees who’re completely depending on maize, or what it meant for all the opposite industries across the mining business. That actually had an excellent impression on South Africa this yr.
Read:
Value of SA mining manufacturing breaks by means of R1trn mark
SA not getting full slice of commodity growth
South Africa tax take exceeds finances estimate for second yr
RYK VAN NIEKERK: You referred to the platinum group metals which did nicely, however in your view which commodity sector or section in our mining business carried out greatest or maybe the worst? Which of those stood out?
KOBUS NELL: Ryk, the most effective by far have been corporations with fairly massive exposures to coal, as a result of that was the commodity that – if one seems at its value motion – went up virtually in a straight line. Companies that benefited significantly from coal are Thungela, which was virtually 2X or 250% up within the yr thus far. And then corporations like Glencore, which additionally has a giant publicity to coal, was virtually 50% up. Exxaro as nicely, which has a comparatively excessive publicity to coal, though a lot of its coal is bought to Eskom at fastened tariffs, additionally went up virtually 50%. So these undoubtedly stood out.
And when you take a look at coal itself, coal is just a bit over 100% up yr thus far. That was undoubtedly the one the place one might see the distinction.
I feel it’s nonetheless necessary to present a little bit background to those excessive coal costs. Coal is a substitute for the very excessive fuel costs seen in Europe, the place coal is principally seen as a substitute vitality supply to fuel, with a type of price-movement relationship, particularly in Europe.
Of course, the fuel value rose so steeply due to Russia which – as has been broadly mentioned in the course of the yr – severely restricted its provides to Europe. As we noticed, that triggered huge harm to the European economic system … But for these promoting coal it has been a implausible yr.
RYK VAN NIEKERK: But I additionally assume that right here coal and specifically iron ore have been negatively affected by the issues Transnet skilled and the issues we had in getting merchandise aboard ship and exported. It is one factor for the value to be excessive, however when you can’t get it to the place you need it, or the place individuals are ready to purchase it, the chance will dissipate.
KOBUS NELL: Absolutely, Ryk. As you see, if the product is there and our consumers are there, you may realise these forms of earnings – not solely for the corporate and others, however, as I mentioned, to the advantage of the nation and its taxpayers.
Yes, I feel it’s very irritating. Speaking to mining corporations in the course of the yr one might actually hear the nice frustration, and one would hope that correct consideration is being given to the matter. It’s such a straightforward supply from which we and the nation can capitalise, and we now have sadly simply not seen that functioning.
Read:
Extortion ‘mafia’ hits SA’s virtually R1trn mining sector
Transnet declares pressure majeure on coal export line to Richards Bay
Thungela mints cash as Ukraine warfare sends coal costs into orbit
RYK VAN NIEKERK: And then which industries do you assume fared worse than others?
KOBUS NELL: If you embody the packaging corporations, Mondi had a extremely poor yr. It was one of many poorest shares by way of returns, and that’s one thing not often seen. Mondi was normally in the course of the pack. It had a really troublesome yr. Nevertheless, the corporate remains to be comparatively good corporations it’d want to purchase, in addition to an improved dividend on that facet. That was relatively fascinating.
Our valuable metals for this particular yr didn’t do this nicely. If you take a look at platinum by way of 4% … not a giant rise there. But the actually massive value will increase have been decrease than final yr. Absolute value ranges are nonetheless very excessive and the margins are nonetheless very excessive. But for a mining business to actually do very nicely by way of yield one usually must see that the underlying metals or commodity value should rise.
This has held the platinum corporations considerably again this yr as a result of they have been up between 4% and three%, maybe not what many anticipated, and so they appear very low-cost if one seems on the multiples. And, as I discussed, the costs at absolute ranges are nonetheless very excessive and in lots of buyers eyes I feel maybe at ranges they don’t think about sustainable.
RYK VAN NIEKERK: Generally, when there’s a surge within the business and the mining corporations get some money into the financial institution one sees a flush of company offers. We haven’t seen that many this yr. Impala Platinum and Northam are competing to take over Royal Bafokeng Platinum. It’s an fascinating combat. And then Gold Fields wished Canadian Group Yamana, however that deal additionally fell by means of. Chris Griffith resigned as chief govt after that occurred.
Did I miss some other massive transactions that came about?
KOBUS NELL: Not actually, Ryk. Rather, it was within the earlier yr and years earlier than that that lots of the corporations tried to rid themselves of coal, the environmentally unfriendly publicity. And amongst these are unbundlings like Thungela, coming from Anglo American. But mining corporations’ general margins final yr and even this yr, it’s actually wonderful that the mining corporations – and I’m talking of world mining corporations – have been so disciplined.
As the principle motive, if listeners assume again, some would possibly keep in mind that in 2014/15 there was an enormous bear market within the commodity world. Some of those corporations have been actually on the purpose of rights points or at promoting massive belongings, having taken on big indebtedness from, one would possibly say, 2008 to 2012 …
So you had revenue margins as excessive as these within the good instances from 2012 onwards, when the Chinese had quite a lot of credit score and excessive demand in 2008, simply earlier than the worldwide monetary disaster, and the Chinese had sturdy development. They didn’t considerably improve their purchases. That’s why one now sees very sturdy free money stream for many of those corporations.
The one exception, maybe – and also you talked about it – is the love triangle between Impala, Northam Platinum and Royal Bafokeng Platinum, the place Impala and Northam Platinum are concentrating on Royal Bafokeng Platinum’s land.
The land [ore body] nonetheless has a really lengthy life, is comparatively shallow and in an space have been we now have seen little or no growth prior to now who is aware of what number of years. With the scenario by way of electrical autos, the lowered variety of conventional autos utilizing conventional platinum catalytic converters, there’s nice uncertainty concerning the demand going forward for these metals and people autos. That could also be why we now have seen little or no funding. But the belongings that stay buoyant are what the blokes are combating for.
Read:
Chris Griffith calls it a day at Gold Fields after botched Yamana deal
PIC received’t promote stake key to RBPlat takeover battle
The battle for Royal Bafokeng Platinum hits the house stretch
RYK VAN NIEKERK: Then lastly, what do you anticipate for subsequent yr?
KOBUS NELL: Ryk, I feel if one seems at funding in commodities, one has to think about cycles. They are cyclical investments, when one seems at them, and I feel they may all the time be. If we glance again, mining corporations reached their peak on a relative foundation round February 2022. In actually a yr, from February 2021 to February 2022, the mining sector went up a little bit greater than 60%. There have been corporations up way more, however the common was 60%.
Interestingly, from February 2022 – when the Ukraine-Russia warfare broke out – we noticed these highs. And when you take a look at a few of your indicators for copper, oil, the motion within the greenback – you normally see strengthening of the greenback in a bear market – and another issues, they point out that the bear market presumably led to February 2022. That has in fact not been confirmed, however since then mining shares have underperformed, particularly if one considers them on a relative foundation. So I feel that’s the primary necessary factor we went by means of.
If one excludes the three months throughout Covid when commodity costs fell closely however rapidly recovered, we had seen a really prolonged commodity bull market – principally counting from 2016 to, say, the start of this yr.
So I feel one has to maintain behind one’s thoughts that mining firm margins have been at report excessive ranges, as excessive as we noticed in that distinctive interval for commodity demand. So I feel if all that’s put collectively and also you take a look at normalised earnings and at these type of issues, the mining sector just isn’t buying and selling at exceptionally low-cost ranges. Because of the very excessive present cyclical margins it’d look appear so, however that wasn’t the case. So I feel one has to grasp that was an amazing interval, however it’s behind us.
As for subsequent yr, the one factor I think about vital is the rise in rates of interest which appears to ‘want’ to abate or decelerate, as we now have seen.
Usually that occurs on the level [when] commodities are additionally not doing too nicely. I feel in 2023 we shall be getting into such a interval. We are speaking of rates of interest not being minimize, however presumably abating. That shall be damaging.
Then I feel the Russian warfare shall be extra widespread. Its pushing of fuel and coal costs up just isn’t good for demand, as a result of many companies can not function profitably. That’s additionally a damaging we have to take a look at, the financial downturn in Europe. They devour some 20% in base metals, 10% to fifteen% in iron ore, and even 40% to 50% in platinum group metals. That, too, is a giant danger.
And lastly, as we are saying, the one optimistic that we might see is China’s reopening which you may have seen since they introduced buying and selling once more in commodity costs. But it’s primarily vitality that they anticipate – and oil costs – could be supported if there’s higher exercise. Again, that doesn’t bode nicely for mining corporations’ enter costs.
I feel it’s going to be a tougher yr, Ryk, following an excellent interval for buyers. But I feel there are nonetheless particular alternatives that one would possibly see, relying on how the warfare in Ukraine performs out and has an impression. But I feel one has to see it as an funding comparatively late in a cycle which may very well be filled with challenges in 2023.
RYK VAN NIEKERK: Kobus, thanks a lot for time this night. That was Kobus Nell, a portfolio supervisor at Stanlib.
