You may take heed to this podcast on iono.fm (*6*).
JIMMY MOYAHA: Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan has come out to sentence Stage 6 load shedding, saying that Eskom must take away Stage 6 instantly and in addition conversations round attainable sabotage as to why that is taking longer than vital.
I’m joined on the road in the meanwhile by Roger Lilley and Chris Yelland, each gents impartial power analysts, to a have a look at this Stage 6 load-shedding scenario, and decide whether or not or not this will represent an power disaster.
Good night, gents. Thank you very a lot to each of you to your time. I feel the plain query earlier than we kick off the dialog is: Is this a disaster or do we have now to attend for additional load-shedding phases? At what level will we name what we’re experiencing a disaster as a rustic?
CHRIS YELLAND: Well, my view is that that is definitely a disaster and has been so for a very long time. And it’s evident from the truth that the president has arrange a so-called National Electricity Crisis Committee to take care of this disaster. So I don’t suppose there’s any argument; we’re within the center of a disaster.
JIMMY MOYAHA: Chris, out of your perspective we all know that President Ramaphosa established the National Electricity Crisis Committee. Can you shed some gentle on what that committee was established for? Is this not the time for them to intervene? Do we have now to attend for a bit extra earlier than we will discuss with them? There was clearly the assertion from their aspect to say that they’re assembly on a weekly foundation – however what are these conferences translating to?
CHRIS YELLAND: Remember, the National Electricity Crisis Committee was established by President Ramaphosa with a view to implement the president’s plan.
The president consulted broadly and developed the plan. In my view, personally, the plan is approach too advanced.
It follows the everyday president’s strategy. In different phrases, seek the advice of very broadly, after which attempt to appease every stakeholder in a really advanced plan. I feel it’s unnecessarily advanced.
But nonetheless the disaster committee has been arrange and a quantity of working streams or work teams have been established. They are busy apparently engaged on this.
One of the issues is that each one the individuals within the National Electricity Crisis Committee and its work streams have needed to signal a secrecy settlement.
Now, I don’t actually have an issue with that, as a result of you possibly can’t have each Tom, Dick and Harry on the committee and work streams speaking to the media on a regular basis.
But for those who’re going to do this, then it is advisable set up not less than a central [point of contact] or a spokesperson or someone who can carry on speaking to the general public, as a result of if in case you have a secrecy settlement with everyone, the fact is there may be communication popping out of it, actually, as to what they’re doing and what they’re reaching, and what the outcomes are.
And so we truly don’t know. I’ve a worry that that is evolving into what we have now had earlier than twice, the place warfare rooms have been established which in the long run have achieved little or no aside from being a chat store. But I hope I’m mistaken. I hope there may be actual good work being achieved.
I consider there may be actual work being achieved however, as common, it’s being stopped on the stage of the DMRE [Department of Mineral Resources and Energy] and Nersa.
And actually, it’s attention-grabbing to see whether or not the president has sufficient will to impose on these two organisations to make them get issues achieved and unblock these blockages.
JIMMY MOYAHA: We’ll come again to that ‘will’ dialog simply now, Chris. I simply need Roger [Lilley] to offer us some context as to some developments that we noticed as nicely. We noticed that the City of Cape Town and the City of Tshwane each established or activated their disaster-management operation centres in consequence of Stage 6. Now, these two cities are huge metros within the nation. They’re contemplating this a disaster-level occasion, or getting ready for it to be a disaster-level occasion. Should we not be bracing ourselves as shoppers or as residents of the nation, on condition that two of our greatest cities or two of our greatest metros have activated their operation centres for this. Is there one thing that they know that we don’t know?
ROGER LILLEY: Good night. Thank you. You’re proper. We needs to be much more involved than we’re.
We appear to just accept Eskom’s feedback in regards to the varied causes for load shedding, however this has been occurring for 15 years now.
So if it was a disaster, it’s been a disaster within the making for a lot of, a few years, and admittedly the South African authorities and the officers therein have sat on their palms and allowed this to occur.
I used to be most amazed after I learn what Minister Gordhan needed to say in phrases of his outburst of outrage with load shedding Stage 6, as a result of he acts as if that is one thing surprising, that is one thing that caught him without warning, when in truth that is on the playing cards.
We know very nicely that is going to occur. So a disaster, certainly it’s a disaster. It has brought on immeasurable harm to the financial system. It has value so many individuals their jobs, it has destroyed overseas funding alternatives and so forth and so forth. This is definitely a disaster.
JIMMY MOYAHA: I like that you just talked about the overseas funding alternatives and the erosion to the financial system, Roger. From Eskom’s perspective, or slightly from a rustic’s perspective, what ought to we do? Are we to put Eskom underneath impartial administration, are we responsible the administration, are we responsible the federal government? You talked about one thing fairly vital, saying that Pravin Gordhan because the minister of public enterprises got here out and was shocked by one thing that has been plaguing the nation for 14-odd years, if not longer – since most likely about 2008 or so. Is the federal government nonetheless allowed to be shocked at this stage, or ought to they be doing extra to intervene at a nationwide stage?
ROGER LILLEY: Well, I feel the reply to that’s pretty clear, and I’m certain everyone listening to this could be capable to provide the similar reply.
Of course the federal government must do extra. The authorities is solely accountable by its personal alternative.
Having arrange a monopoly for the era of electrical energy, it’s subsequently solely accountable to verify we have now that electrical energy, each reasonably priced electrical energy and dependable electrical energy, and neither are true.
There is nobody else responsible. There is nobody else responsible.
What’s actually attention-grabbing is that the one approach we’re going to get out of this example is by taking it out of the federal government’s palms and placing it within the non-public sector’s palms, as a result of the second we get the non-public sector concerned, we instantly discover out that each one the shenanigans that go on don’t go on in private-sector involvement. We don’t have the identical ranges of corruption and criminality and so forth and so forth.
So actually that is the one approach ahead for me. And a typical instance, if I may divert barely, is that this. Yesterday I used to be within the automobile and I used to be listening to the radio, and I heard the minister of well being being quoted as saying that he acknowledges the truth that the South African state doesn’t have sufficient ambulances. But, by no means thoughts, he advised parliament – I’ve made an association with Netcare 911 and they’ll assist us out.
So there you might be. Immediately, the second there’s an issue, name within the non-public sector and, guess what? The drawback goes away. Why can’t we do this with the power sector?
We’ve been crying about this for, what, 5 years now, six years now, and nothing’s taking place.
JIMMY MOYAHA: Now Chris – Roger makes a vital level there to say that it is a drawback that the federal government has created, and it’s for them to then repair.
As one other instance, we noticed in 2020 that we went right into a nationwide lockdown and instantly our authorities’s ministers had the powers to impose alcohol bans and that kind of factor in instances of a disaster, and in instances of an emergency.
Surely this emergency scenario ought to warrant that the powers that be have the authority to make it simpler for impartial energy producers to carry all of the purple tape and to deal with the difficulty?
CHRIS YELLAND: Yes, I agree precisely with that. I feel the time has come that management on this nation wants to start out ensuring proclamations.
I’ll give an instance – wheeling tariffs. Municipalities have been speaking about municipal wheeling for the final 10 years. To date we would not have a municipal wheeling framework, and wheeling tariffs don’t exist in any of the municipalities. This is basically holding issues up.
Likewise, feed-in tariffs, tariffs for which clients will receives a commission for extra surplus renewable power generated by photo voltaic PV battery methods generated again into the municipal grids. Only one municipality, or shall I say one or two, have municipal feed-in tariffs.
This is a main instance the place I feel management must step in and, by proclamation, proclaim not less than for a interval of, say, two years, a nationwide wheeling framework and a nationwide feed-in tariff in order that we will get fast incentives for small-scale embedded era and battery storage, and there will likely be incentives to do that.
The similar factor applies, for instance, to tax breaks on the home stage. There are tax breaks on the business stage for companies. But the identical incentives, tax incentives, may very well be utilized for personal people during which primarily the price of a photo voltaic PV battery system may be expensed and deducted from one’s taxable earnings.
This offers a big tax discount and incentive that makes the enterprise case a lot stronger, and would lead to a right away uptake massively of photo voltaic rooftop PV and battery storage across the nation.
This may be achieved by proclamation in the identical approach because the Covid emergency. There had been guidelines proclaimed nearly in a single day. This is the type of strategy that needs to be taken in an emergency, and we’re not seeing this sort of motion in any respect.
JIMMY MOYAHA: Yes, we have to see firmer motion and extra concrete motion from all stakeholders concerned. In the occasion that Eskom shouldn’t be privatised or the federal government refuses to revisit the privatisation dialog – as a result of that’s been a theme prior to now the place it’s been dropped at the federal government’s consideration to, say, semi-privatise, privatise totally – and the federal government has mentioned that that’s not an choice.
Should we then be taking a look at municipalities producing their very own power? I ask this solely as a result of, for those who have a look at the City of Cape Town for example, whereas the remainder of the nation is on Stage 6, there was a degree the place the City of Cape Town was on Stage 5 as a result of that they had various power coming by way of by approach of a hydro pump. So ought to we then say to all municipalities that may self-govern or that may govern higher, they need to be allowed to acquire their very own electrical energy outdoors of Eskom?
CHRIS YELLAND: Yes, that needs to be the case. And in truth now it’s the case. At first we need to simply say that I don’t suppose privatising Eskom is the difficulty or not the difficulty.
I feel Eskom is all the time going to be a significant participant, nevertheless it clearly at present can not meet its obligations. And it has a burden that we have to help Eskom with.
And after I say ‘we’, I’m speaking about clients of electrical energy, as a result of the extra clients [that] put in self-generation, higher era, distributed era, wheeling the facility to the grid, the extra we relieve Eskom of a burden which it at present is unable to satisfy.
So these items needs to be inspired. They needs to be allowed, and they need to be incentivised.
The similar applies to municipalities. Municipalities are clients of electrical energy from Eskom, and there’s no cause why they shouldn’t [be], and in reality they’re, taking a look at procuring energy from various sources aside from Eskom, from impartial energy producers.
That doesn’t imply to say that town goes to declare independence, or the province goes to declare independence and go off the grid. Not by any means.
It means they’re supplementing the power wants with various power provides which can be greener, cleaner, and in reality at a decrease value. This controls the price. It does what municipalities are speculated to do, which is to try to take care of and serve the most effective pursuits of their clients throughout the municipal group to get them the least-cost, most dependable and most accessible electrical energy.
So they need to be doing it. They are doing it. There are clients of electrical energy for instance in Cape Town which can be producing into the grid and getting paid for it. Cape Town can be taking a look at procuring electrical energy from impartial energy producers into the group to complement their power wants, and diversify from, in the meanwhile, unique electrical energy coming from Eskom.
And so I foresee sooner or later the place that Eskom has – however alongside Eskom, a quantity of various or impartial energy producers competing on value, on service, on availability, on cleanness to complement power wants, so transfer away from a monopoly system to a multi-market system.
JIMMY MOYAHA: Roger, one closing query. I’ll give this one to you. Are we in danger of a grid collapse and, in that case, what occurs if the grid collapses? Are we ready for it as a rustic? Are companies ready for it? And is it a actuality we would should confront?
ROGER LILLEY: Well, it’s a actuality that we would should confront. But I can inform you that the very last thing that Eskom needs is a grid collapse as a result of it’ll take one thing like two weeks to get out of it once more, to get energy again up. And even when it comes up, it’ll come up very slowly and it’ll take a very long time earlier than we’re even again to Stage 6. It will likely be far worse than that.
So we actually don’t need that.
Load shedding is designed particularly to forestall a collapse. That’s precisely why it’s implied. So you actually have a scenario the place the load needs to be balanced with the producing capability.
Now, Eskom has for a few years been calling out for increasingly producing capability to offer it respiration area in order that it may take some of its older energy stations down, both mothball them or pack them up or restore them, no matter needs to be achieved in every case. But this can’t be achieved until we get further energy, and we have to get that further energy rapidly.
Now we thought issues had been transferring ahead properly earlier within the yr when the president introduced that we’d be capable to have embedded era as much as 100 megawatts with no licence, and we actually did anticipate an uptake of that. I’m unsure what the delay has been there as a result of that basically goes to make the distinction after we begin to get extra producing capability on-line.
And, as Chris has defined, even when it’s for their very own use, if a enterprise invests in its personal era for its personal use if for no different use, not less than it removes half of the load from Eskom and helps Eskom and offers it the respiration area it wants, albeit from a unique perspective.
JIMMY MOYAHA: Yes. And for some companies that is perhaps a price that they’re keen to incur, as a result of the profit far outweighs what they’re going by way of in the meanwhile.
But I assume we’ll have to attend and see what Eskom does or what they are saying to us, and what the nationwide authorities does in phrases of interventions.
But gents, thanks very a lot to your time. That was Roger Lilley and Chris Yelland, each impartial power analysts, chatting to us in regards to the present power disaster that we discover ourselves in.
