SIMON BROWN: I’m chatting now with Thalia Petousis, portfolio supervisor at Allan Gray. Thalia, I recognize the early morning time. The commodity boom – I used to be going to say significantly in power, however honestly it’s throughout a broad swathe of commodities – one would anticipate actually some good profit coming via for the African continent, however you make the purpose that that’s not necessarily all of the case. For instance, in Nigeria they’re producing about half the oil they have been a decade in the past. And after all they’ve received the gas subsidy, which is consuming into their accessible spend.
THALIA PETOUSIS: Yes, that’s a nice level and truly your slip-up once you mentioned ‘energy boom’ may be very apt as effectively, as a result of there was this boom in power costs and for many commodities really power costs have surpassed the value will increase of different commodities that we might suppose the African continent as being wealthy on. So, for instance, a place like Kenya – they’re importers of oil, the value of which has risen in a short time in greenback phrases, however they export commodities like like cocoa and flowers, and their costs have simply not been rising as quick. So what does that end in?
Well, this commerce imbalance implies that they’ve really had a greenback scarcity within the economic system, and we’re seeing that greenback scarcity throughout a few countries inside Africa. It’s fairly problematic as a result of countries actually need {dollars} for their imports, a few of them being important imports like meals and gas. They want additionally to service their debt, and lots of of those countries, we all know, have huge quantities of greenback debt sadly. So actually the commodity boom that I’d say we have now now emerged from has actually not been sufficient to work wonders on the continent. Moving costs can not do all of it. The setting on the bottom additionally must be fairly conducive to progress.
SIMON BROWN: That was going to be my query. Obviously we get [it] that commodities are cyclical. Everyone is aware of that. But maybe these economies form of haven’t positioned themselves correctly. The one instance maybe is having greenback debt, though I recognize elevating debt in Nigerian naira or the Kenyan shilling merely may not be that viable.
THALIA PETOUSIS: Well, they do elevate a lot of local-currency debt, however as quickly as you’ll be able to elevate greenback debt you open your self as much as your complete offshore funding group, who’s way more eager, who has these dollar-denominated emerging-market debt funds. In the previous couple of years they’ve had monumental urge for food for African and frontier market debt, and the explanation for that’s that offshore rates of interest have been extremely low. And within the US in 2020 we received to a level the place the in a single day charge of curiosity was 0%, and in Europe it was about adverse.
This wasn’t one thing that simply popped its head up in 2020. For a interval of about 40 years rates of interest in developed markets have been dropping. During that point, and particularly in the course of the later a part of that point, I’d say the final decade of that fall in rates of interest, a lot of cash began to circulation out of the core of the monetary markets – being the US, the UK, the entire of the EU – and into peripheral markets like these throughout the African continent as a result of buyers have been on this nice hunt for yield.
Now sadly this meant that in 2018 a nation like Ghana got here to market to boost $3 billion of debt they usually received $20 billion value then from an offshore base. It’s weird. I believe on the time it was one thing like a third of the dimensions of their economic system in a single public sale on a single day; that was what was on provide. So actually I believe some countries have ……3:58 on debt and people debt-service prices have been very problematic for a place like Nigeria, [which] you talked about. It’s consuming nearly a hundred % of presidency tax income paying again curiosity on that debt. But it means then governments can’t spend in direction of the place they should within the economic system.
But I believe one other large purpose why a value boom in commodities can’t work wonders alone is that basically there should be growth-enhancing reforms at place within the economic system. There must be a pleasant enterprise and funding setting, there must be clear and efficient coverage. And the massive one clearly, which we’re all accustomed to, is there must be entry to power and electrical energy.
SIMON BROWN: Is there a case to be made that in the course of the good occasions – resembling Ghana has out of the blue discovering themselves with $20 billion of debt – there was a possibility there when issues have been wanting higher to make reforms, and it merely hasn’t occurred. Of course now all that cash is dashing again to the US. We are seeing rampant greenback energy as a result of you’ll be able to put your cash in a five-year American treasury and get 4%.
THALIA PETOUSIS: It is dashing again, and that dashing again is inflicting points, partly as a result of foreigners received’t be there to refinance debt when it matures, and a few of it’ll mature within the subsequent 12 months and the following two years. That’s why I believe fairly broadly there’s an expectation out there that Ghana will default on its debt.
Should they’ve executed one thing otherwise? Well, it’s stunning with Ghana. They really export oil – and you know the way the power value has risen – however they don’t have a refined gas capability on-line. So they’re not capable of refine gas domestically within the economic system. Because of that they find yourself exporting oil and importing refined gas. That then leads out of the commerce steadiness, negates the optimistic affect of their exports.
And then just like South Africa, they’ve had ageing electrical infrastructure, ageing power infrastructure. They’ve had non-cost-reflective electrical energy tariffs and really low assortment charges from prospects. So [it’s] actually the SA mannequin form of there. And then on high of that, as we’ve mentioned, this enormous burden of debt that’s raised in {dollars} that’s now changing into extraordinarily tough to service, particularly [at] the time when the Ghana cedi has misplaced about 40% of its worth within the final 12 months.
So this greenback debt actually sends African countries to the doldrums when they’re hurting essentially the most as a result of the fiscus is weak, the foreign money begins to weaken, and on the identical time their debt pile – which is denominated in {dollars} – merely grows.
They have approached the International Monetary Fund for help with restructuring their debt and we’ll should see what takes place there.
SIMON BROWN: It is a big problem, and luckily within the South African setting we have now little or no non- Zar debt, which is I believe a saving in lots of sense.
Thalia Petousis, portfolio supervisor at Allan Gray, I recognize the early morning.
Listen to the total MoneywebNOW podcast each weekday morning right here.